Plaintiff to provide
2009 年 3 months, Danfeng County, Shaanxi Province, occurred Shangluo causing death by torture Rong Xu stems event. At that time, Danfeng senior high school grade students, 19-year-old stems Rong Xu who were killed by suspected Detention. March 8, due to face torture, Xu Rong stem death during the trial. Video: High school students question the families of sudden death by torture trial Source: Shaanxi TV, March and April 2009, and Xu Rong stems three net posts related to the incident, leading lives in Xi'an Zhang Guoqing, Zhang Bai Qing Shangluo brothers has been taken away by police, 10 days in administrative detention Zhang Guoqing, Zhang Bai Qing because of defamation
2009 年 11 months, the post into the case of private prosecution, Zhang Qing-Bai who was four Shangluo police court.
Rong Xu Terrier event thread libel trial
reporter leaves Iron Bridge Sun Haihua
2009 年 3 8, Rong Xu incident stems, online talking about, which caused three net posts Shangluo City, Shaanxi Province, the police's attention, these three net posts were found with Police Shangluo Zhang Guoqing, Zhang Qing-Bai brothers are related, they were subsequently detained.
net posts directly involved in these three Shangluo Municipal Committee, Political secretary and party secretary He Tiehu Municipal Public Security Bureau. One wrote: . Danfeng political commissar of the Public Security Bureau is the king of holes have been the driver of a leader, was promoted to wind sick, so how security, political commissar of the police contingent. The case will be more and more. Shangluo City (Committee) Standing Committee, Politics and Law Committee secretary, party secretary of public security bureau two days He Tiehu several whole body against the wind force is promoted so that the public security demons disease: a traffic police captain Raoyu Ming Shan County, Last year, drivers of farm vehicles with a death sentence for the murder of people, (by) the party a serious warning; one people sulked in Zhashui Zhang Jun, deputy director of the Public Security Bureau; one is specifically for He Tiehu plot opposite, pick up opponents, the Xu Rong-case guide stem deputy chief of the city criminal police detachment Li Jianfeng (ministries and agencies, drunk driving was reported as )。files files provided explicitly wrote: wing death and defamation Shangluo Municipal Committee, secretary of Politics and Law Committee, Party Secretary He Tiehu Municipal Public Security Bureau investigated the content. practices. November 2, Shangzhou Public Security Bureau issued When the Secretary has apologized for Zhang Guoqing.
3 days after November 6, Shangzhou in Xi'an Public Security Bureau police found two Zhang Bai Qing, has brought against book
2009 年 11 19, Bai Qing Zhang received the court summons and was told that due to the net posts involving four parties, 4 of District People's Court pursuant to subpoena Zhang Bai Qing in at 9:00 on November 23 criminal courts to the Court to accept the
the four private prosecutors were Shangluo City Public Security Bureau Criminal detachment commissar Li Jianfeng, Shangluo City Public Security Bureau patrol special police detachment Zhang Dan, Hill County deputy police chief Rao Yuming, Danfeng County Wang Hongwei, political commissar of the Public Security Bureau.
2009 年 11 23, Zhang Bai Qing and counsel to the District People's Court Shangzhou objection to jurisdiction. Shangzhou District People's Court decided to reject, Zhang Bai Qing appeal, Shangluo City Intermediate People's Court ruled that revocation of Shangzhou District People's Court ruling. Ultimately, the case go to Xi'an Yanta District People's Court.
in the November 5, 2010 in the trial, the four agents of the private prosecutor read out the complaint 4. Wang Hongwei plaintiff claimed that, on the people talking about me, friends and family have called to ask about my condition,
Monster Davis Tribut, walking in public places often hear people do not know about me ... ... want to know my body has been very good, not sick, for a time I do not know how to explain to friends and family are afraid to go out, restless, often in a deep trance, at night, unable to eat anything, the spirit of extreme tension ... ... Shangluo City Public Security Bureau who has been on file for investigation Shangzhou Branch, identified as Zhang Bai Qing committed, I was surprised, I have no work, and Zhang Qing-Bai travel, life, and no interaction, but in August 2006 a daughter for colleagues off of the banquet, to be introduced only through the understanding of it. I have no contact with his prime, no injustice Wu Chou, really can not figure out why he to insult and slander me ... ... responsibility.
for But Zhashui County Public Security Bureau, Zhang leadership to me, everyone knows that Zhang mean me.
Zhang Dan said: , reviews, tens of thousands of users thread, condemnation over the place, a non-existent, fabricated slander other people's posts with the rapid evolution of the major news events involving the police. is a great insult and defamation ... ... like a bolt from the blue, give me the spirit and reputation of a blow on the insult and defamation of my character caused great damage to ... ... this information into a time that I did not eat at night sleepless state, trance, distracted, resulting in a depression ... ...
In addition, Li Jianfeng, and Rao Yuming are all described in the suit their own spiritual being of
Bai Qing Zhang argued that constitutional guarantees of freedom of expression and citizens against any person the freedom to criticize and make suggestions. He said he did not know the four private prosecutor, and they have no grudges, hatred, and he did not intend to slander others, it can not accept his case.
Zhang Bai Qing China Youth Daily in an interview that the development process from the case can be seen, the power behind the public mischief. Previously, he was detained on suspicion of criminal libel, but according to XingJu a private prosecution to. Although later corrected, but he have a say in the process of being told
Zhang Bai Qing believes that these prosecutions are in Shangluo City Public Security Bureau carried out Shangzhou Zhang Bai Qing Branch of withdrawal occurs after the case, He said that access to private prosecution stage, more people pop up with
Bai Qing Zhang Yao Yongan defender also believes that the police Shangluo special status of four private prosecutor is a strong character, is suspected of abuse of public power. Things they have no legitimate complaint Zhang Bai Qing evidence of slander, but can not be said of crime, the matter of the complaint can not be established, should be dismissed.
case there is no court verdict. Newspaper on November 18 in Xi'an Xinhua
Xu Rong event stems and then pull the thread libel case in the case
whistleblower complaint letters into the prosecution evidence was
11 On 5 March, the event thread Rong Xu defamation case stems in Xi'an Yanta District People's Court. Surprisingly, the case once again pull voir dire.
2009 年 3 months, Danfeng County, Shaanxi Province, occurred Shangluo causing death by torture Rong Xu stems event. At that time, Danfeng senior high school grade students, 19-year-old stems Rong Xu who were killed by suspected Detention. March 8, due to face torture, Xu Rong stem death during the trial.
Rong Xu Terrier triggered a post with the case. March and April 2009, and Xu Rong stems three net posts related to the incident, leading lives in Xi'an Zhang Guoqing,
Louis Vuitton Jewelry, Zhang Bai Qing Shangluo brothers has been taken away by police, 10 days in administrative detention Zhang Guoqing, Zhang Bai Qing because of defamation
2009 年 11 months,
GHD IV Dark Styler, the post into the case of private prosecution, Zhang Qing-Bai who was four Shangluo police court. (See November 25, 2009 China Youth Daily reported)
year later, the case in Yanta District People's Court. However, the case once again pull voir dire, report Zhang Bai Qing defamation, in addition to four Shangluo police persons, added two, one is the Shaanxi Provincial People's Air Defense Office (hereinafter referred to as Shaanxi Province is the assessment of a former deputy director of the Office of De-Min Wang.
It is understood, Zhang Qing-Bai is a retired Civil Air Defense Office of Shaanxi Province Administration cadres.
more surprising is that their evidence, there are several letters addressed to the relevant departments of the anonymous complaint letters, and letter of the report object, it is their own.
written discipline and unit head of the main leaders of the complaint letters, to be an informer in the hands
11 5 January for a full day hearing, the court around 4 am Zhang Bai Shangluo Police v The celebration commenced defamation, the afternoon's trial is the Du Cheng Zhang, Min Wang v. Zhang Bai Qing.
China Youth Daily reporter obtained Tu Cheng chapters of the Zhang Bai Qing, the same - Press Note) because the total assessment unit at the provincial level than front row, that all this is caused by the unit leadership. So for serious dissatisfaction with the status of the unit, one after another to the provincial department of the relevant units , leadership, and all cities Civil Air Defense Office distributed anonymous speech on the plaintiff to attack. , Tu Cheng Zhang said the plaintiff from 2005 to intervene after the Civil Air Defense Office of Shaanxi Province in Xi'an, Xianyang, Baoji, Hanzhong, Ankang and other places some of the works, a little slack to make things difficult for people finding fault; run classes repeated use of money 20 million engaged in corruption; the province in 2007 annual inspection of protective equipment in designated enterprise security risks openly shielding; operation of equipment into the subway safety hazards. In addition, the defendant Zhang Boqing in the bar's CCTV community bar, Shaanxi urban bar, Oriental TV bar, bar, etc. Urumqi Evening News openly published dozens of online media, titled Engineering multi-hazard to relatively poor results of the unit, from their own to find a cause, to work seriously to find problems, improve work standards' requirements, all the blame on the NPC deputies and CPPCC members, is detrimental to the pot of soup, a mouse, strongly urge the provincial investigation of political whore Min Wang. he Department veteran cadres at the provincial Civil Air Defense Office wrote on their computers, Civil Air Defense Office of the evaluation ranking inform Liu Xun Lin, flagrant violation of the organization and discipline. Contents serious distortion of facts, is purely fabricated, the plaintiff has been caused to the two great mental stress and loss of reputation, the nature is very bad ... ... the defendant's conduct has caused a series of bad social influence and political impact,
replica watches store, have been consistent with the characteristics of libel constitute defamation, the court shall be prosecuted for criminal responsibility should be. At the same time given to the plaintiff the defendant's conduct has caused irreparable mental damage, the plaintiff special civil part of the additional 10 million compensation for moral damage. During the trial, these allegations, the lawyer Zhang Bai Qing Cheng Du chapter Min Wang Yao Yongan required to produce the original evidence.
to their surprise, the other court to produce a number of reports sealed envelope with the original letter. These complaint letters, only two did not specify a particular recipient, the rest are written for specific people: when he has to discipline head of the Civil Air Defense Office of Shaanxi Province, Shaanxi Province, is currently deputy director of Civil Air Defense Office Cheng Du Wu Wenhai reflect the problem of the correspondence of Chapter 4 ; have to Shaanxi Province Civil Air Defense Office Director Peng with the meaning reflected Du Cheng Zhang problem of the correspondence 4; have to Shaanxi Province Civil Air Defense Office of Discipline Inspection Group Supervision Office responsible in Du Cheng Zhang problem of the correspondence 1; have to Shaanxi Province Civil Air Defense Office secretariat comrades Tu Cheng chapter issues letter a; there are other people turn to the letters three, a total of 13.
units of the main leaders of the complaint letters, not only not read the Department report to the audit results, but to be an informer in the hands, become an informer against defamation of evidence!
more they surprise, a plaintiff in court the other evidence presented, Zhang Qing-Bai's office suffered from a search.
unit organized a search party defendant's office
This , at 18:30 on March 30th, 2009, head of the provincial discipline inspection group of Civil Air Defense Office of Comrade Wu Wenhai, organs retired Deputy Director of Service Management ... ... for Zhang Boqing Shirong Chang comrades used the office computer hard drives were demolition, the specific process is as follows:
Shirong Chang Zhang Boqing office door open; Li Qing opened its use of the computer, remove the computer hard drive under the two; Cai Kehua dismantled drive model on-site registration and storage for; Zheng Hongyu Zhang Boqing into the office and demolition of the whole process of the scene camera, Yuan Jianmin process of demolition and sealing of the shooting scene, the whole process in the discipline inspection team leader, Comrade Wu Wenhai under the supervision of ... ... The plaintiffs also produced a involved in the original documentation, post, browse the web content. Test results showed that identification center in the hard disk
Yaoyong An attorney alleged that the illegal search, illegal search. discipline inspection departments handling the case, this search also appears inconceivable: was with these letters match the content, we can not prove that the complaint letters that Zhang Bai Qing wrote, that this matter is not clear.
Min Wang also told reporters by telephone, Zhang Qing-Bai When asked what sources through these letters, Min Wang said:
case there is no court verdict.
newspaper on November 18 in Xi'an Xinhua
sudden death of family members of high school students questioned torture trial Source: Shaanxi TV,
Students reported trial sudden death libel letter
Linear Mode
